Skip to main content

Episode 53: The Search for Identity Leads to Foster Care Ministry

By July 16, 2018January 3rd, 2023Podcast

"Helping people know they aren’t alone and that they are understood is huge."

Holly Miller was born into foster care and was adopted at the age of seven by the family with whom she had been in a long-term placement. The adoption conversation was always open, but she as she grew, she found she had more questions than answers because she simply didn’t know much about her life before her adoption. Her journey of working through the “who am I” questions led her down an interesting path that has recently resulted in a ministry that combines her passion for foster and adoptive children and their families with a need in her community.


Holly doesn’t remember life prior to being in foster care because she was placed in care almost immediately after she was born. Her mother wasn’t able to provide for her due to difficulties brought about by her own mental illness. She tried, and even though Holly’s biological grandmother did what she could to help, it was still too difficult to create and maintain a healthy environment.

At seven years of age, Holly was adopted by the family with whom she had lived as a long-term placement. She had had home visits with her biological family, so the adoption conversation was simply part of her story. Even as a young child, she felt somewhat confused as to why she had two families. “It was tough. I remember being anxious—I had a lot of questions. I didn’t understand why I was the only one in this situation,” she says.

Expressing her questions and feelings at a young age was not easy, so her frustrations often came out as anger or crabbiness. Thankfully, sports became an outlet for her, and she had good teachers who worked with her in academic areas.

Although she was the only adopted child in her school that she knows of, it wasn’t something other kids talked about or teased her about. They knew what was happening, but didn’t necessarily have a good understanding of what it all meant.

About 2-3 years after she was adopted, Holly started having more questions about her adoption, most revolving around her identity. Why me? What was wrong with me? and Why did I have to be adopted? were common questions she asked. “Why me was the big feeling I had, and I didn’t really know how to express it,” she explains. It wasn’t really until she was in high school that she could put words to her feelings.

A high school English assignment in her freshman year finally allowed her to grasp what she was missing. “It was a creative writing assignment that didn’t have to be biographical, just something you could relate to. So I used myself as an example, but I got to the point where I had so many questions as I was trying to create a story that I couldn’t even finish the assignment.” Questions like “What did my dad look like? Where was I born? There were so many gaps…I just didn’t know and it was very frustrating.” Holly had been used to starting her “story” at the age of seven, but this assignment brought out the gaps. Even though she was in a safe, stable family, she still struggled with the gaps in her story and found it hard to understand.

Who am I?

Searching for her identity and figuring out who she was led her to become a motivated athlete. “It became who I was, even though in reality it was a false identity. I just avoided the feelings from the age of 16-17 to my mid-20s. But, of course, they didn’t really go away.”

A series of injuries allowed her to more deeply examine the “who am I” question—and it was through these injuries that she ended up finding the Lord. “I found the answer of who am I…I am God’s child!” Holly credits the Lord for allowing her to reach a physical breaking point to break her spirit so that the Holy Spirit could speak truth and love into her soul.

She had a severe injury that prevented her from playing soccer—or any sports—for a while. During this time, her friends invited her to church and youth group. Several times after surgeries, she woke up to people praying over her. One of these times, she felt the Holy Spirit telling her “Holly, you are loved,” and she simply accepted Christ right then. That experience ignited a purpose in her life and two weeks later, she enrolled in Bible college.

New Hope 4 Kids

Currently Holly works in children and family ministries at New Hope Church in the Twin Cities (Minnesota). When she started there two years ago, she noticed there were a significant number of adoptive and foster families, so it became a natural community to reach out to support each other as well as support others in the community. This turned into a new ministry called New Hope 4 Kids, which supports and encourages those in foster and adoptive situations, as well as provides ways to express God’s heart for children by offering resources, training and counsel to encourage community and give hope. “Who knows what He’s going to do with this, but He’s got great things in store!” says Holly.

New Hope 4 Kids and Bonnie, TFI’s local Advocate were able to work together during the church’s VBS Camp. The service project for the week was to support the local foster care community by filling TFI Journey Bags. “We were humbly overwhelmed at the response,” says Holly. More than 100 Journey Bags were filled and prayed over at the end of the week. “The families loved learning more about foster care and being a part of helping others.”

For those considering Foster Care

Holly’s advice for those considering foster care is to simply take the next step. If you’re familiar with foster care, but you’re overwhelmed and it feels like too much, find out what the resources are in your area, or the people who know what the resources are. “Take that next step of doing more,” she encourages. If you don’t have experience with foster care and you’re wondering what you can do, one

idea is to find out how you can support a foster or adoptive family. Simply hanging out, encouraging, praying and sharing are all ways you can help. “God will show us what the next steps are. Helping people know they aren’t alone and that they are understood is huge.”

Advice to foster and adoptive parents

Holly’s advice to parents whose children are or may (most likely will) experience confusing feelings about their situation is to spend time and develop trust with your child—starting at a young age. “Ask if they have anything they want to talk about. Keep the conversation open—draw them out with stories or, with younger children, have them draw their feelings. Big feelings can surface at any time.” Make sure your constant message is “You are enough. I love you. I’m thankful to be your mom” so that when those questions come up, they will know you are with them and for them.


New Hope Church
New Hope Facebook
New Hope Instagram
Holly’s Facebook
Holly’s Instagram


The TFI Story
Who Loves Series
Find a TFI Advocate Near You
Become a TFI Advocate


Hopefully, this episode has helped you right where you are on your foster care journey. That’s the goal. If you enjoyed it, will you tell others?

The best way to do that is to rate the podcast on Apple Podcasts and leave us a brief review! Your ratings and reviews help us get this podcast in front of new listeners. Your feedback also lets us know how we can better serve you. Thank you so much!

Meet Our Guest

Holly Miller is passionate about sharing the hope of Jesus with youth who are impacted by adoption and foster care especially as these kids navigate the realities of their lives. This passion helped birth a ministry called New Hope 4 Kids, which is a place to learn more about God’s heart for children as well as learn how to practically help and advocate for marginalized children. New Hope 4 Kids provides resources, training and counsel to help the local church meet needs in their community. Holly, her husband, Jason, and their daughter live in Maple Grove, Minnesota.

Get practical episodes and updates in your inbox.

Be the first to know about new episodes, posts, resources, and stay in the loop about what’s coming up.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Other Episodes You Might Enjoy:

Episode 124: From Foster Youth to Foster Parent to Social Worker

| Podcast | No Comments
In this episode, we have the incredible privilege to welcome Jaymi Lynn, who has experience across the gamut of foster care. Jaymi is not only a social worker today, but also a foster and adoptive…

Episode 141: Encouragement, Hope, & Practical Help for the Christian Foster Parent

| Podcast | No Comments
Jamie Finn is back on the podcast this week! On top of being a foster parent, Jamie is the host of the Real Mom Podcast, co-founder of Goods & Better, and the director of Foster…

Episode 117: Living a Life of Compassion and Surrender

| Podcast | No Comments
This week’s guest is Amanda Auer, a mom of 4 who has an incredible story walking through a difficult journey of kinship care. You’ll hear her talk about what it was like to be educated…